Reproductive Exploitation & Surrogacy: Why Black and Brown Women Hesitate
On Fertility Ground Surrogacy

Surrogate Advocacy

Why Black and Brown Women Hesitate About Surrogacy: The History Behind It, and How to Vet an Agency

November 18, 2026 · 11 min read · On Fertility Ground Surrogacy

Updated November 10, 2026

Why Black and Brown Women Hesitate About Surrogacy: The History Behind It, and How to Vet an Agency

If you are a Black or brown woman who has paused at the idea of becoming a surrogate, or a Black or brown family who has hesitated to hand your embryo and your hopes to an agency, that hesitation is not paranoia. It is memory.

For generations, the people who were supposed to care for our bodies took from them instead. Some of that history is distant. Some of it is within living memory. And some of it is still showing up in the numbers today.

At On Fertility Ground, we start here because trust is not something an agency can ask for. It has to be earned, and it cannot be earned by pretending the history isn't there. This article walks through what happened, why it still matters inside a surrogacy journey, and the specific practices that separate an agency you can trust from one you cannot.

What Actually Happened

This is not a complete history. These are the chapters we hear about most from the women and families we talk to.

Experimentation on enslaved women

In the 1840s, physician J. Marion Sims performed experimental gynecological surgeries on enslaved women in Alabama — among them Anarcha, Lucy and Betsey — without anesthesia and without any ability for them to consent. He is still sometimes called the father of modern gynecology. Published research in the Journal of Medical Ethics documents how that record shaped, and continues to shape, the relationship between Black women and reproductive medicine.

The Tuskegee study

From 1932 to 1972, the U.S. Public Health Service tracked roughly 600 Black men with syphilis and withheld treatment, even after penicillin became the standard cure. The men were never told the truth. The CDC's own account of the study is public, and worth reading in the agency's own words.

Forced and coerced sterilization

In 1961, civil rights leader Fannie Lou Hamer was sterilized without her consent during surgery for something else. The practice was so routine in the South it was nicknamed the "Mississippi appendectomy."

Out west, between 1968 and 1974, more than 200 women — most of them Latina — were sterilized at Los Angeles County-USC Medical Center, many while in labor, some told to sign or their baby would die. Ten of them sued in Madrigal v. Quilligan. The judge ruled for the doctors in 1978, finding the sterilizations stemmed from communication and language barriers rather than intent — but the case drove better informed-consent rules in California, including bilingual consent materials for patients who do not speak English as a first language. Los Angeles County formally apologized in 2018, and later installed a permanent memorial to the survivors on the hospital campus.

These were not rogue acts. They happened inside hospitals, performed by licensed physicians, under the cover of public health and population control.

By the Numbers

In 2024, the maternal mortality rate for Black women was 44.8 deaths per 100,000 live births — compared with 14.2 for white women and 12.1 for Hispanic women.

Source: CDC / National Center for Health Statistics, 2026 release

Why It Still Matters Today

This isn't only history. Black women die from pregnancy-related causes at more than three times the rate of white women, and that gap is not simply a matter of who can reach a hospital. A 2023 study in The Lancet Regional Health – Americas examined 13 million births and found that Black mothers living in the least vulnerable counties — the ones with the best resources and access — still faced higher risk of maternal death, preterm birth and low birthweight than white mothers living in the most vulnerable ones. Access alone does not explain it.

If you have ever felt dismissed in an exam room, had your pain minimized, or had to push to be taken seriously, you already know what those numbers feel like from the inside.

So when a Black or brown woman considers carrying a pregnancy for someone else, or a family of color considers trusting someone to carry theirs, the question "will I be protected?" is not a hesitation to talk someone out of. It is exactly the right question.

What This Looks Like Inside Surrogacy

Surrogacy has its own history, and a Black woman sits at the center of the case that shaped it.

In Johnson v. Calvert (1993), Anna Johnson, a Black nurse and single mother, agreed to carry a baby for Mark and Crispina Calvert for $10,000. When the relationship broke down during the pregnancy, both women asked the court to declare them the mother. The California Supreme Court ruled that Crispina Calvert, the intended mother, was the legal mother, and that gestational surrogacy contracts are enforceable.

That ruling made gestational surrogacy legally workable, and it is one reason California is the state most surrogacy law gets measured against today. It also showed how quickly a surrogate can find herself with the least power in the room once a dispute starts.

The cases in the news right now carry the same lesson. When a contract is vague about medical decisions, when an agency isn't watching the journey closely, or when the surrogate doesn't have her own attorney, the risk lands on her first. For a Black or brown woman who already navigates a healthcare system that doesn't always listen, that risk is not abstract.

Bree — Founder & CEO

From Our Founder

Bree — Founder & CEO, On Fertility Ground

I did not open with this history to be provocative. I opened with it because of what I actually hear from the women who come to us — and it is usually not doubt about themselves. It is the people around them.

A mother, a sister, a best friend, a whole church community who hear the word surrogacy and immediately hear something being taken from her. That reaction comes from the history you just read, carried down through our communities, and from how rarely anyone has explained it alongside what surrogacy actually involves today.

So when a woman tells me her family is against this, I don't treat it as an obstacle to get around. Those people love her, and their concern is not coming from nowhere. My job is to give her the knowledge and a safe place to work it through — and to answer their questions too, if she wants me in that conversation. Nobody should have to defend this decision alone.

— Bree | info@onfertilityground.com · Meet Bree →

When the Doubt Is Coming From the People Who Love You

In our experience, the hesitation is often not hers alone. Plenty of the women we talk to are fairly settled in their own decision, and then run into a wall of worry from the people closest to them — a mother, a partner, a sister, a friend who is certain this is something being done to her rather than something she has chosen.

That worry traces straight back to the history above. It is also rarely paired with any real information about how gestational surrogacy works today: that she has her own attorney, that the medical decisions remain hers, that the baby she carries was never genetically or legally her child to give up. When the only thing a family has to go on is the history, the history is what they go on.

We don't ask anyone to go argue with her family. We do two things instead — make sure she has the knowledge to answer those questions in her own words, and make ourselves available to the people around her if she wants us in that conversation. Our guide to talking to your family about becoming a surrogate was written for exactly this.

What Earning Trust Actually Looks Like

Trust is built from specific, checkable practices, not a warm welcome page. Here is what we hold ourselves to at On Fertility Ground, and what you should look for in any agency you consider:

  • Your own attorney. Every surrogate should have independent legal counsel reviewing her contract before she signs — not the intended parents' lawyer, and not the agency's. In California this is law, not a courtesy: Family Code section 7962 requires separate counsel of your own choosing, paid for by the intended parents.
  • Plain-language contracts. Medical decision-making language, especially around termination and complications, should be explained to you in scenarios, not handed over with a signature line.
  • A real escalation path. When something goes wrong mid-journey, you should know exactly who you call and what happens next — a named person, not a ticket queue.
  • Regular check-ins, not silence. You should hear from your coordinator on a set schedule through the pregnancy and after delivery, including the postpartum months when the medical risk is highest and most agencies have already closed the file.
  • Vetting that runs both ways. Every agency screens surrogates thoroughly. Ask how they screen intended parents, too.
  • People who understand your context. You should not have to explain why a dismissive provider, a family's reaction, or a cultural expectation matters to you. (This is what we mean by BIPOC-affirming support — it is a practice, not a tagline.)

If an agency can't answer these questions clearly, take that as information. Our 10 questions to ask before becoming a surrogate is built to be read aloud on a first call.

You Are Allowed to Ask Hard Questions

We built On Fertility Ground for the communities the surrogacy industry was not specifically created to protect: Black and brown women and families, LGBTQ+ families, and single parents by choice. We don't ask you to set your skepticism aside. We ask you to bring it.

If you want the fuller picture of where the industry still falls short and what we do differently, read what Black, brown and BIPOC surrogates deserve and why Black women are underrepresented in surrogacy. If you would rather just talk, that works too.

Reach out at info@onfertilityground.com or 510-808-6948. Ask us the hard questions. We would rather answer them now than have you find out the answers later.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it normal to be nervous about surrogacy as a Black or brown woman?

Yes, and it is not irrational. American reproductive medicine has a documented record of experimentation and coerced sterilization carried out on Black, Latina and Indigenous women inside licensed hospitals, some of it within living memory. A reputable agency should answer questions about safety and protections directly rather than treating caution as a problem to manage.

Are Black women still at higher risk during pregnancy?

Yes. The CDC reported a 2024 maternal mortality rate of 44.8 deaths per 100,000 live births for non-Hispanic Black women, compared with 14.2 for non-Hispanic white women and 12.1 for Hispanic women. The 2023 Lancet Regional Health study found that Black mothers in the least vulnerable counties still faced higher risk than white mothers in the most vulnerable ones — which points to causes beyond access to care alone.

Does a surrogate get her own lawyer?

In California she must. Family Code section 7962 requires the gestational carrier and the intended parents to each have separate, independent legal counsel of their own choosing, and the carrier's attorney is paid for by the intended parents. If an agency suggests sharing a lawyer, or offers to review the contract on your behalf, that is a reason to walk away.

What was Johnson v. Calvert and why does it matter to surrogates?

It is the 1993 California Supreme Court case that made gestational surrogacy contracts enforceable in California. Anna Johnson, a Black nurse and single mother, had agreed to carry a baby for Mark and Crispina Calvert for $10,000; when the arrangement broke down, the court held that the intended mother was the legal mother. It is why California became a surrogacy hub, and it is also a reminder of how quickly a carrier can become the person with the least power in a dispute.

How do I tell whether a surrogacy agency is actually safe?

Ask for specifics rather than reassurance: independent counsel of your own choosing, contract language explained in scenarios instead of clauses, a named person to call when something goes wrong mid-journey, a set check-in schedule through pregnancy and after delivery, and how they screen intended parents and not only surrogates. If an agency cannot answer those clearly, treat the vagueness as the answer.

Sources

Ready to Learn More?

Whether you're considering surrogacy as a surrogate or an intended parent, we're here to answer every question personally.

Email us at info@onfertilityground.com — We answer every inquiry personally.

This article is general education, not medical or legal advice. Surrogacy eligibility is determined case by case by a fertility clinic's physician and a licensed reproductive attorney, and surrogacy law varies by state. Written by Breana "Bree" Luster, Founder & CEO of On Fertility Ground Surrogacy.

Last reviewed November 10, 2026 by Bree, Founder & CEO of On Fertility Ground Surrogacy.

Keep reading

← Back to the blog